Use a separate email for this
Almost every form sends a confirmation link, so you'll need an email address. It doesn't have to be your main one. DuckDuckGo Email Protection gives you a free @duck.com address that forwards to your real inbox without revealing it.
A plus address like you+optout@gmail.com also lands in your normal inbox (Gmail supports it) and makes the confirmations easy to filter, but the site still sees your real address. Keep a regular address handy too: PeopleConnect's form turns some addresses away with "Task specific emails are not allowed." If a confirmation doesn't show up within a few minutes, check spam.
What they'll ask for, and why
Nearly all of them want an email for the confirmation link. Spokeo, Whitepages and PeopleFinders also want the web address of your listing, so they remove you and not someone with the same name. Whitepages calls a phone number to confirm. PeopleConnect asks for your date of birth and sends a code to a phone or email. That's Them and MyLife want your street address to match the record.
None of the opt-outs we could see require a Social Security number or a photo of your ID. A couple offer an optional SSN field. Leave it blank. And don't correct mistakes on your listing: a wrong birthday on there is doing you a favor.
When a listing comes back
It will, eventually. Most of the free sites say so in their own privacy notices: they keep pulling in new public records, so a move or a new phone number can create a fresh listing that your old opt-out doesn't cover. They suggest refreshing your opt-out now and then, and for once they're right.
Search for yourself every three months (the calendar file reminds you), opt out again, and if a site keeps putting you back, send it the email request above. In California, DROP makes registered brokers repeat the deletion every 45 days on their own.
Search like a stranger would
Open a private window and search your full name with your city, then your phone number, then your street address. That's exactly what someone looking for you would do. Anything on the first two pages of results is part of your real list, so work it alongside this one.
What this can't do
Public records stay public. County property records, court filings and, in many states, voter rolls are open by law. An opt-out hides the profile a site built from them. The record itself is still there for anyone who goes looking.
Your own posts aren't covered. Social media profiles, tagged photos, an old résumé on a job site: none of that is a people-search listing, so none of these opt-outs touch it. Lock those down separately.
It isn't a force field. There are hundreds of data brokers. This list covers the big people-search sites and a few of the brokers behind them. If someone is trying to find you, talk to a victim advocate about your state's address confidentiality program, which lets survivors use a substitute address.